Just a short ferry ride from historic Christiansted, Hotel on the Cay is a private island hotel offering a distinctly St. Croix experience. Spend your days on the beach, enjoy views across Christiansted Harbor and the Caribbean Sea, and return to the comfort of a recently renovated room or suite.
Experience private island living at Hotel on the Cay, featuring recently renovated rooms and suites with private balconies overlooking Christiansted Harbor, Fort Christiansvaern, the Caribbean Sea, or the beach. Choose from king rooms, two-queen rooms, and spacious suites, perfect for romantic escapes, family vacations, or island getaways with friends.
Say "I Do" on Protestant Cay
Exchange vows on a private island surrounded by Caribbean water and the beauty of St. Croix.
From intimate beachfront ceremonies to larger celebrations with family and friends, Hotel on the Cay offers a truly distinctive setting for a destination wedding.
Hotel on the Cay puts you in a unique position to experience both Christiansted and the wider island of St. Croix.
Explore historic sites, discover local restaurants and shops, get out on the water, snorkel and dive, take a tour or simply spend the day enjoying the beach.
Whether your St. Croix vacation is about adventure, history, food, relaxation or time together, Hotel on the Cay gives you a private island place to come home to.
Hotel on the Cay puts you in a unique position to experience both Christiansted and the wider island of St. Croix.
Explore historic sites, discover local restaurants and shops, get out on the water, snorkel and dive, take a tour or simply spend the day enjoying the beach.
Whether your St. Croix vacation is about adventure, history, food, relaxation or time together, Hotel on the Cay gives you a private island place to come home to.
Every room at Hotel on the Cay has a private balcony, but each side of the island offers a different perspective.
Sunrise views across Christiansted Harbor
Located on the eastern side of Protestant Cay, Bay View accommodations look across Christiansted Harbor toward the morning sun.
Beach and Caribbean Sea views
Located on the western side of Protestant Cay, Beach View accommodations overlook the beach and Caribbean Sea, creating a beautiful setting for enjoying the island's sunsets.
Views toward historic Fort Christiansvaern
Harborview Fort accommodations look across Christiansted Harbor toward historic Fort Christiansvaern and the waterfront of Christiansted.
More space for families and small groups
Our suites provide additional living space and thoughtful features for guests who want more room to relax, gather and settle in.
There is something different about waking up surrounded by water.
Hotel on the Cay sits on Protestant Cay in Christiansted Harbor, giving you a private-island setting just across the water from historic Christiansted.
Step outside onto your private balcony. Walk to the beach. Watch boats move through the harbor. Enjoy the changing colors of the Caribbean. Then take the ferry into Christiansted whenever you're ready to explore.
Private island. Historic town. One uniquely St. Croix experience.
Enjoy casual island dining without leaving Protestant Cay. For additional dining options, several restaurants are located at King Christian Hotel next to the ferry pickup in historic Christiansted.
Enjoy barbecue, seafood and vegetarian options in a relaxed island setting.
Relax with a drink, enjoy the waterfront setting and take in the laid-back atmosphere of the beach.
Enjoy barbecue, seafood and vegetarian options in a relaxed island setting.
Relax with a drink, enjoy the waterfront setting and take in the laid-back atmosphere of the beach.
