Our Pool Is Temporarily Closed.

Rooms & Suites at Hotel on the Cay

Stay on a Private Island in Christiansted Harbor

Hotel on the Cay offers a collection of recently renovated rooms and suites on Protestant Cay, a private island in the heart of Christiansted Harbor. Every accommodation features a private balcony and its own perspective of Christiansted Harbor, historic Fort Christiansvaern, the Caribbean Sea or the beach.

Choose from king rooms, two-queen rooms and spacious suites designed for couples, families and small groups. Whether you prefer a sunrise view across the harbor, a sunset-facing beach setting, or views toward historic Fort Christiansvaern, each accommodation gives you a comfortable place to relax while experiencing St. Croix from a truly distinctive private-island setting.

Choose Your Room

Find the view, layout and space that fit your St. Croix stay.

Bay View Rooms

Sunrise views across Christiansted Harbor

Located on the eastern side of Protestant Cay, Bay View rooms offer views across Christiansted Harbor and the morning sun. Choose a king or two-queen configuration, each with a private balcony.

Explore Bay View Rooms

Beach View Rooms

Beach and Caribbean Sea views with sunset-facing orientation

Located on the western side of Protestant Cay, Beach View rooms overlook the beach and Caribbean Sea. Each features a private balcony where you can enjoy the island breeze and the changing light as the day comes to a close.

Explore Beach View Rooms

Harborview Fort Rooms

Views toward Fort Christiansvaern and Christiansted Harbor

Harborview Fort rooms look across Christiansted Harbor toward historic Fort Christiansvaern and the waterfront of Christiansted. Choose a king or two-queen configuration, each with a private balcony.

Explore Harborview Fort Rooms

Suites

More space for families, small groups and longer stays

Our suites offer additional living space and thoughtful features for guests who want room to relax, gather and settle in. Suite accommodations are well suited to families, small groups and longer St. Croix stays.

Explore Suites

Which Room Is Right for You?

Choose your accommodation based on how you want to experience St. Croix.

For Couples

Our king rooms offer a comfortable private-island retreat with a private balcony and your choice of harbor, beach or Fort Christiansvaern views.

Explore King Rooms

For Families & Friends

Our two-queen rooms provide comfortable accommodations for families and friends traveling together, with private balconies and a choice of island views.

Explore Two-Queen Rooms

For More Space

Our suites provide additional living space and are ideal for families, small groups or guests planning a longer stay.

Explore Suites

For Sunrise Views

Choose a Bay View room for an eastern-facing perspective across Christiansted Harbor and the morning sun.

Explore Bay View Rooms

For Beach & Sunset Views

Choose a Beach View room for a western-facing setting overlooking the beach and Caribbean Sea.

Explore Beach View Rooms

For Fort Christiansvaern Views

Choose a Harborview Fort room or suite for views across Christiansted Harbor toward historic Fort Christiansvaern.

Explore Harborview Fort Rooms & Suites

Compare Rooms & Suites

AccommodationBed TypeSleepsApprox. SizeViewPrivate Balcony
Bay View KingKing3290 sq. ft.Christiansted Harbor / SunriseYes
Bay View Two QueensTwo Queens4336 sq. ft.Christiansted Harbor / SunriseYes
Beach View KingKing3290 sq. ft.Beach / Caribbean Sea / SunsetYes
Beach View Two QueensTwo Queens4336 sq. ft.Beach / Caribbean Sea / SunsetYes
Harborview Fort KingKing3290 sq. ft.Fort Christiansvaern / HarborYes
Harborview Fort Two QueensTwo Queens4290 sq. ft.Fort Christiansvaern / HarborYes
Harborview Fort One-Bedroom SuiteKing + Sleeper Sofa6580 sq. ft.Fort Christiansvaern / HarborYes — Two Balconies

View All Rooms & Suites

Pick options to filter the list
  • Filter:
Viewing: 7 of 7
  • Balcony with two bar stools overlooking a turquoise bay with sailboats under a blue sky.
    A modern bedroom shows a white bed, wall TV, dark-green vanity, and a doorway with curtains.
    A cozy corner with a rattan armchair, tall green plant, small cabinet, and a white-shaded table lamp.
    A modern bathroom vanity with an oval sink, mirrored wall, and a white orchid on the counter.
    A modern bathroom with a toilet, glass shower, and geometric tile-pattern walls.
    • Ocean View,
    • King,
    • Sleeps 3

    ​ Sleeps 3 | 290 sq ft

    Bay View - King

    Greet each day with panoramic views of Christiansted Harbor as the sun rises over the calm Caribbean waters. Located on the eastern side of Hotel on the Cay's private island, the Bay View King offers a peaceful waterfront retreat where gentle sea breezes, passing sailboats, and ever-changing island scenery create an unforgettable escape. Designed with a relaxed, island-inspired aesthetic, the room features a plush king bed, contemporary furnishings, and a private balcony that invites you to slow down and soak in the view. Just a complimentary ferry ride from historic Christiansted, you'll enjoy the perfect balance of secluded island serenity and vibrant waterfront charm

    BOOK NOW

  • Balcony with a round table and two stools, looking out at a turquoise beach, palm trees, and boats beyond.
    A modern bedroom with a white bed, wall-mounted TV, wooden dresser, and an entryway with a dark-green kitchenette.
    A cozy corner with a leafy plant, a beige lamp, and a small wooden cabinet against white tiled walls.
    A balcony with two black bar stools and a round table, overlooking palm trees and a blue ocean under a cloudy sky.
    Modern bathroom with a white countertop sink, dark vanity, mirror, and a potted white orchid.
    Small modern bathroom with white toilet and glass shower cubicle, featuring geometric tile walls.
    • Ocean View,
    • King,
    • Sleeps 3

    ​ Sleeps 3 | 290 sq ft

    Beach View - King

    Located on the western side of Hotel on the Cay's private island, the Beach View King overlooks swaying palms, soft white sand, and the turquoise waters of the Caribbean Sea. Spend your days just steps from the beach, then watch the sky transform into brilliant shades of gold, orange, and pink as the sun sets beyond the horizon. Inside, warm natural finishes, contemporary coastal décor, and a plush king bed create a peaceful retreat inspired by the beauty that surrounds it. Your private balcony offers the perfect place to unwind while taking in one of St. Croix's most memorable views.

    BOOK NOW

  • A bright hotel bedroom with a bed, TV, rattan chairs, and curtains, overlooking a lake and green hills.
    A modern bedroom with a lit bed, TV on the wall, a wooden console, and a small kitchen pass-through with green cabinets.
    Bright coastal bedroom/living area with patio doors, rattan chairs, a bed, lamps, and lush greenery beyond.
    A sunny balcony with two black bar stools and a round table, looking out over the turquoise bay with palm fronds and boats.
    Balcony with two black chairs and a round table overlooking palm trees, turquoise water, and distant hills.
    A modern bathroom vanity with a white sink, black faucets, a wall mirror, and a potted white orchid on the counter.
    A modern bathroom with a white toilet and a glass shower enclosure featuring bold geometric black-and-gray tile patterns.
    • King,
    • Sleeps 3,
    • Ocean View

    ​ Sleeps 3 | 290 sq ft

    Harborview Fort Room - King

    A serene island retreat featuring a plush king bed and sweeping views of Fort Christiansted and the sparkling harbor. Wake to gentle sea breezes and watch boats drift across turquoise waters from your private vantage point. Ideal for couples seeking a romantic and relaxing Caribbean escape.

    BOOK NOW

  • A bright, cozy hotel bedroom with two made beds, warm ceiling fan, wood door, and woven décor elements.
    Balcony with a round table and two chairs overlooking a turquoise bay with sailboats and a coastal town.
    Bright modern living room: green cabinet, floating shelves, potted plant, rattan chair, and oval wall mirror.
    A modern bathroom vanity with an oval sink, lit mirror, and a white orchid on the countertop.
    A modern bathroom with a white toilet and a glass shower, featuring geometric black-and-white tile walls and a grab rail.
    • Ocean View,
    • Queen,
    • Sleeps 4

    ​ Sleeps 4 | 336 sq ft

    Bay View - Two Queens

    Perfect for families and friends, the Bay View Two Queen bedroom overlooks the tranquil waters of Christiansted Harbor from the eastern side of our private island. Wake to breathtaking sunrises, watch sailboats glide across the bay, and enjoy a front-row seat to one of St. Croix's most picturesque waterfront settings. Featuring two queen beds, island-inspired décor, and a private furnished balcony, this spacious retreat offers a relaxing place to recharge after a day of exploring the island or unwinding by the water.

    BOOK NOW

  • A bright hotel room with two beds, chairs, a lamp-lit TV stand, and a balcony view of hills and palm trees.
    A bright modern bedroom with two beds, a ceiling fan, woven accents, and warm wall decor.
    A bright hotel room with a bed, chair, floor lamp, and a balcony view of a calm bay and hills.
    A bright cozy corner with a green cabinet, wooden mirror, potted leafy tree, and cushioned chair by a shelf.
    Balcony with two black chairs and a round table, looking out on a turquoise bay, sailboats, hills, and a palm frond.
    A balcony with two black chairs and a round table overlooks turquoise water, palm trees, and green hills under a blue sky.
    A modern bathroom vanity with a wall mirror, dual faucets, a white countertop sink, and a potted white orchid on it.
    A modern bathroom with a toilet and a glass-enclosed shower featuring bold geometric tile patterns and a black grab bar.
    • Ocean View,
    • Queen,
    • Sleeps 4

    ​ Sleeps 4 | 290 sq ft

    Harborview Fort Room – Two Queens

    Designed for comfort and connection, this spacious room offers two queen beds and front-row views of Fort Christiansted and the lively harbor. Perfect for families or friends, enjoy the balance of vibrant waterfront activity and peaceful island surroundings.

    BOOK NOW

  • Balcony with two black stools and a round table, overlooking palm trees and a blue bay under a sunny sky.
    A bright modern bedroom with two beds, a ceiling fan, woven decor, and warm wood doors.
    Bright living room corner with a green cabinet, tall potted plant, oval wall mirror, and wicker chair beside sofa.
    A modern bathroom vanity with a wall mirror, dual faucets, and a potted white orchid on the countertop.
    A modern bathroom with a white toilet and a glass shower, featuring bold geometric patterned tiles and a black grab bar.
    • Ocean View,
    • Queen,
    • Sleeps 4

    ​ Sleeps 4 | 336 sq ft

    Beach View - Two Queens

    Designed for families and friends, the Beach View Two Queen offers sweeping views of the beach and Caribbean Sea from the western side of our private island. Spend the day relaxing on the sand or exploring the crystal-clear waters before returning to your private balcony to watch the sun dip below the horizon. With two queen beds, inviting island-inspired décor, and a spacious layout, this room provides the perfect setting for an unforgettable Caribbean escape.

    BOOK NOW

  • A bright modern living room with wood furniture, woven rug, a ceiling fan, and large sliding doors revealing a lakeside view.
    A modern living room with a ceiling fan, TV console, armchairs, and a round wooden coffee table.
    A modern hotel bedroom with a white bed, wall TV, wooden dresser, green cabinet, and a wood door in a bright living space.
    A cozy living room with a wood ceiling fan, dark sofa, armchairs, a round coffee table, and warm light through large walls.
    A sunlit modern bedroom with a large bed, TV, curtains, and a balcony view over lush green hills and water.
    Bright living room with gray sofa and armchair, oval coffee table, ceiling fan, and large windows overlooking a lake and hills.
    Bright modern living room with rattan decor, sofa, coffee table, ceiling fan, and palm views through big glass doors.
    Balcony with two black chairs and a table, palm fronds, and a bright blue ocean view with hills and clouds.
    • Ocean View,
    • King,
    • Sleeps 6

    ​ Sleeps 6 | 580 sq ft

    Harborview Fort One-Bedroom Suite

    Your private island sanctuary with added space to unwind. This one-bedroom suite features a separate living area with a sleeper sofa, two full bathrooms, two private balconies and a wet bar in the separate living area that is ideal for extended stays or small groups. Take in panoramic views of Fort Christiansted and the harbor from both spaces, blending history with laid-back luxury.

    BOOK NOW

Recently Renovated Rooms & Suites

A Fresh Take on Your Private Island Stay

Your private island experience should be just as comfortable inside your room as it is outside.

Our recently renovated rooms and suites combine updated interiors and modern comfort with the relaxed character of a Caribbean island stay. Comfortable beds, refreshed bathrooms and thoughtfully designed spaces create a welcoming place to return to after a day at the beach, exploring Christiansted or discovering more of St. Croix.

And with a private balcony in every accommodation, you always have your own outdoor space to enjoy the Caribbean breeze and the views surrounding Protestant Cay.

Explore Our Rooms & Suites

Every Room Comes With a Private Balcony

At Hotel on the Cay, every guest room and suite includes a private balcony, giving you your own outdoor space to enjoy the island breeze and the waters surrounding Protestant Cay.

Depending on your accommodation, your balcony may look toward Christiansted Harbor, historic Fort Christiansvaern, the beach or the Caribbean Sea.

It is one of the simple pleasures of staying on the Cay: stepping outside your room and immediately feeling connected to the water and the island.

Stay on an Island. Explore Christiansted.

Hotel on the Cay gives you two experiences in one: a private island setting in Christiansted Harbor, with historic Christiansted just across the water.

Spend the morning on the beach, take the ferry into town to explore Christiansted's historic waterfront, restaurants and shops, then return to Protestant Cay and leave the activity of town behind.

Private island. Historic town. One distinctly St. Croix experience.

Explore Things to Do Discover the Private Island Experience

Frequently Asked Questions